Impermanence, Dukkha, and Not-Self: Understanding the Three Marks

Short Answer

Impermanence (aniccā), unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), and not-self (anattā) are the three marks of existence — the Pali tradition's concise description of every conditioned experience. This guide explains each mark in plain language, shows why the classical formula extends not-self to all phenomena while the other two marks describe conditioned things, and traces how realization of the marks is understood in Pali sources. It also compares the 'three marks', 'three seals', and 'four seals' terminology of Pali, Tibetan, and Chinese materials.

Buddhist teachers often summarize what can be known and experienced with three short adjectives: things arise and pass (aniccā, impermanence); pursuing what arises and passes never settles for good (dukkha, unsatisfactoriness); and nowhere in it all — not in people, things, or states of mind — is there a permanent, independent essence (anattā, not-self). Together these are the three marks of existence, one of the most widely recognized summaries in Buddhist teaching, and also a practical framework for insight. This guide explains each mark in turn, works through the Pali formula and its unusual scope, shows how the marks connect to neighboring teachings such as the Four Noble Truths and dependent origination, and compares the ‘three marks’, ‘three seals’, and ‘four seals’ terminology of Pali, Tibetan, and Chinese sources. It draws mainly on the Pali-language tradition of Theravada, using four published study sources and clearly flagging editorial examples where they appear.

What Are the Three Marks?

According to the Encyclopedia of Buddhism, the three marks of existence — in Sanskrit trilakṣaṇa, in Pali tilakkhaṇa, in Tibetan phyag rgya gsum (‘three seals’), and in Chinese sanxiang (三相) — are, briefly: impermanence (aniccā), suffering or unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), and not-self (anattā) [1]. The same entry also names them ‘the three characteristics of conditioned phenomena’ and notes that the Pali tradition uses them to distinguish Buddhist beliefs from non-Buddhist ones [1].

The word ‘mark’ carries weight here. Peter Della Santina, writing for DharmaNet, explains that a characteristic is something ‘necessarily connected’ with the thing it characterizes — his example is heat, which belongs to fire in a way it does not belong to water, since water only becomes hot through outside causes [2]. A mark, then, is not an occasional accident but a feature inseparable from what it qualifies. Applied to experience, the claim is universal in scope: whatever is conditioned — whatever arises from causes and supports — is always impermanent and always unsatisfactory, and nothing at all, conditioned or unconditioned, is a self.

Della Santina places this teaching alongside the Four Noble Truths, karma, interdependent origination, and the five aggregates as part of what he calls the doctrinal contents of wisdom — the understanding the tradition says wisdom actually involves [2]. The marks are therefore not an isolated slogan but a description of the very field in which the rest of the teaching operates: the same world whose conditions the Four Noble Truths analyze is this impermanent, unsatisfactory, selfless flux.

The Pali Formula and Its Unusual Scope

The Pali texts state the teaching in a compact formula: sabbe saṅkhārā aniccā — all conditioned things (saṅkhārā) are impermanent; sabbe saṅkhārā dukkhā — all conditioned things are unsatisfactory; and sabbe dhammā anattā — all things (dhammā), without exception, are not-self [1]. The Dhammapada, a well-known verse anthology of the Pali Canon, presents the same formula in three consecutive verses, numbered 277–279.

The scope difference within the formula is significant. Saṅkhārā here means conditioned or compounded things: feelings, perceptions, states of mind, the body, and made things — everything that arises because causes and conditions arise. Dhammā is the wider word: all phenomena, including the one thing that does not arise from conditions, the unconditioned release called nibbāna (Sanskrit nirvāṇa). The formula therefore states that impermanence and dukkha characterize everything conditioned, while not-self characterizes even Nibbāna. Buddho.org’s study guide explains the point directly: Nibbāna is permanent and free of unsatisfactoriness, yet even it has no self, so attaining it cannot mean merging with a greater whole, a divine principle, or anything similar — all of which would presuppose some concept of ‘I’ [3]. Not-self is the widest of the three marks.

Anicca: Everything That Arises Will Pass Away

Impermanence receives perhaps the briefest statement of the three: ‘all that has arisen will pass away,’ as the Pali Canon is often summed up [3]. Whatever begins — a thought, a conversation, a life, a forest, even a mountain on geological timescales — does not hold. This is the first characteristic partly because it is the easiest to verify: experience presents itself precisely as a flow of events already dissolving.

Buddhadhamma, the modern doctrinal manual by the Thai scholar-monk P. A. Payutto, develops the picture in terms of a stream. Rather than a world of static composite objects, the teaching describes all things as streams in which each constituent element comes into being in dependence on other elements, in an unbroken flow of appearance and decline; no single element has an independent, fixed identity, and all are impermanent and unstable [4]. On this view, impermanence is not a fault to be lamented but the basic texture of reality — a natural flow.

Notice what impermanence does not say. It is not a value judgment that everything is bad, and it is not a philosophy of despair. It is a description offered with a purpose: if nothing conditioned lasts, then the search for final security in possessions, relationships, reputations, or states of feeling is misdirected from the start. Traditional teaching connects this with dependent origination (paṭicca-samuppāda): things arise when their conditions arise and cease when they cease, which is precisely why they pass.

Dukkha: Unsatisfactoriness, Not Simply Suffering

English translations of dukkha vary widely; the Encyclopedia of Buddhism glosses the term as ‘suffering/unsatisfactoriness’, and both words are needed [1]. Dukkha plainly includes ordinary pain — sickness, aging, grief. But as a mark of all conditioned things, it points to something subtler. Commentaries in the Pali tradition commonly distinguish three overlapping senses: dukkha as outright suffering, dukkha as the distress implicit in change (even happiness ends, and its ending is felt), and dukkha as the background stress of carrying conditioned experience of any kind — a load that never fully sets down.

This is why the formula can say that all conditioned things are dukkha even while experience contains pleasure [1]. The traditional explanation runs roughly as follows: pleasant experiences are conditioned like everything else, so they cannot be made to last; while an agreeable thing lasts, it depends on supporting conditions that are themselves insecure, and when it ends, the loss arrives. In this technical sense, dukkha names the inability of anything conditioned to provide final satisfaction — a sense long glossed through the image of a poorly fitting axle that keeps turning but never smoothly.

Because the first two marks are so easily misread as bad news, it helps to see them paired with their counterpart. The sources cited here also present Nibbāna as free of dukkha [3]: the teaching locates the unsatisfactory character in conditioned existence precisely in order to point beyond it. Dukkha, in other words, is a diagnosis attached to a proposed cure, not a verdict that nothing can be done.

Anattā: No Permanent Self, Not ‘No Person’

The third mark states that nothing — no person, no object, no state of mind, and no transcendent reality — is a permanent, independent, self-sufficient essence. It denies the reality of any enduring core, sometimes called a soul or essence, that would stand behind experience as its owner. Anattā is often rendered ‘not-self’ rather than ‘no-self’ to preserve this precision: it points to what is absent, rather than declaring that experience does not occur.

What the mark does not deny is equally important. Ordinary personhood continues: names, memories, plans, responsibilities, and distinct character are all acknowledged in practice. The tradition presents anattā as a middle position between eternalism, the belief in an unchanging inner essence, and annihilationism, the view that the person is simply nothing; both extremes were rejected.

Buddhadhamma’s stream imagery supports exactly this reading [4]. If each element of experience arises and passes in dependence on conditions, the word ‘I’ functions like the name of a river — persistent and useful, while the water is endlessly renewed. (The river comparison here is an editorial analogy, but it closely tracks the manual’s stream picture.) When the tradition asks practitioners to examine experience for a self, the expected result is not an eerie emptiness but a discovery of processes: behind the name lives only the flow of conditioned elements described above [4].

The mark’s widest scope comes into view here. Because sabbe dhammā anattā extends not-self to all dhammās, Nibbāna itself is included [1][3]. Buddho.org stresses the practical consequence: liberation cannot take the form of joining or merging with Brahma, a divine principle, or a greater whole, since every such scheme rests on a concept of ‘I’ [3]. This careful contrast with Indian views of a universal self (ātman) shaped centuries of classical debate, and it remains one of the clearest boundary lines drawn by the three marks.

How the Three Marks Work Together

The three marks are best read as three angles on one flowing reality rather than as three separate dogmas. Impermanence grounds unsatisfactoriness: because conditions are unstable, no conditioned state can deliver secure satisfaction. And because experience is a dependent flow rather than the property of a fixed owner — Buddhadhamma says the fluid nature of phenomena is possible precisely owing to the interdependence and insubstantiality of their components [4] — there is no self-nature anywhere for the flux to belong to. Seeing one mark clearly tends to open onto the others.

For this reason, the marks function primarily as contemplative objects. The Pali tradition’s insight meditation, vipassanā, is organized in part around observing these characteristics directly, and the Encyclopedia of Buddhism discusses their realization specifically within vipassana practice [1]. The classical claim is radical: according to the Visuddhimagga, realization of the truth of these three marks constitutes enlightenment [1]. The Buddho.org guide similarly states that direct experiential insight into one of these characteristics ‘opens the gate to Nibbāna’, and that understanding everything as impermanent, unsatisfactory, and without a self releases the mind from desire, hatred, and ignorance [3]. Traditions differ on methods and on the language used to describe realization, and no guaranteed experience follows from any technique; the sources themselves stress not propositions but direct seeing.

An Editorial Example: One Evening, Three Marks

A concrete illustration — editorial, offered for orientation rather than as a scriptural story: you share a long-planned dinner with friends. It is genuinely pleasant, and it is conditioned, supported by cooking, health, company, and circumstance (aniccā). As the evening winds down, plates empty and conversation slows; the pleasant is already slipping away, and the wish to hold it a little longer tightens (dukkha). Later, looking back, you search for the solid ‘someone’ who enjoyed it all — and find only a sequence of tastes, laughter, and warmth arising and passing, without an owner standing behind them (anattā). One ordinary event, three lenses: the same lenses the tradition turns on experience as a whole.

The tradition typically presents such seeing as gradual and supported: ethical conduct, some degree of collectedness, and patient study generally precede deeper insight in the Pali path. Nothing here is a self-guided exercise with promised results; it is an orientation to what the sources describe.

Three Marks, Three Seals, Four Seals: History and Tradition

The classical Pali synthesis

The adjectives anicca, dukkha, and anattā recur constantly in the early Pali discourses, and the tradition itself gathered them into the triad now called the three marks. Many modern introductions treat the triad as a traditional summary of strands already present individually in the early texts; precisely when the collective label crystallized is a matter of scholarly discussion, and the sources here present it as a living framework rather than a datable event. By the time Buddhaghosa compiled the fifth-century Visuddhimagga — noted above for its claim that realizing the marks constitutes enlightenment [1] — the teaching stood at the heart of the Pali system.

Buddhadhamma frames the whole doctrine as a description of natural law: the stream of conditioned phenomena is naturally steady and certain (dhammaṭṭhiti), part of a natural order (dhamma-niyāma) that does not rely for its existence on any god, religion, or prophet; the teacher’s role, on this account, is to discover and explain that truth [4]. The same tradition reads the marks as boundary markers: the encyclopedia records their use in the Pali tradition for distinguishing Buddhist from non-Buddhist beliefs [1] — a boundary-keeping function that Tibetan terminology captures in the language of ‘seals’ (phyag rgya gsum), like an authenticating stamp on a document [1].

Seals and the Mahayana four-seal summary

Tibetan sources name the three marks the ‘three seals’ [1]. The same encyclopedia entry discusses an expanded ‘four seals’ formulation [1], common in Mahayana and Tibetan doctrinal teaching. It is usually summarized in four statements: all conditioned things are impermanent; all contaminated things are dukkha; all phenomena are without self; and nirvāṇa alone is peace. The third statement parallels the Pali formula’s move from saṅkhārā to all dhammā [1][3], while the fourth adds an explicit assertion about what lies beyond dukkha.

Mahayana teaching builds directly on this widening. The Prajñāpāramitā literature and the Madhyamaka school developed the selflessness of all phenomena into the doctrine of emptiness (śūnyatā), extending the not-self analysis to every dharma without exception. For readers crossing from Pali sources, the key point is continuity: the marks remain authoritative in Mahayana contexts even as their implications are drawn further.

In East Asian Buddhism, the same doctrine circulated under the Chinese rendering sanxiang (三相) recorded in the encyclopedia entry [1], with individual schools inheriting and recombining it according to their own emphases. The comparison below is deliberately simplified: traditions vary internally, and labels such as Theravada and Mahayana are descriptive conveniences rather than rigid fences.

FormulationWhere it is usedContentsScope note
Three marks (tilakkhaṇa)Pali texts and the Theravada traditionimpermanence (aniccā), unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), not-self (anattā)First two marks stated of conditioned saṅkhārā; not-self covers all dhammā, including Nibbāna [1][3]
Three seals (phyag rgya gsum)Tibetan rendering of trilakṣaṇathe same three marks‘Seal’ language highlights their use in authenticating a teaching as Buddhist [1]
Four sealsA summary common in Mahayana and Tibetan doctrinal teachingthe three marks plus the statement that nirvāṇa alone is peaceExtends selflessness explicitly to all phenomena; discussed by the encyclopedia as a separate formulation [1]

Common Misunderstandings, Clarified

‘Buddhism teaches that life is nothing but suffering.’ The formula says all conditioned things are dukkha, not that everything anywhere is misery [1]. Dukkha as a mark names the unsatisfactory instability of conditioned experience, which ranges from obvious pain to the subtle stress of pleasant things that end. The same sources present Nibbāna as free of dukkha [3], so the teaching is diagnostic: it locates stress precisely in order to point beyond it.

‘Anattā means I do not exist.’ The mark negates a permanent, independent essence, not the everyday person who plans, remembers, and takes responsibility. The stream picture shows the alternative [4]: a changing process that is real enough to be named and cared for. The tradition itself rejected nihilistic readings — annihilationism — as one of the two extremes the middle position avoids.

‘If everything is impermanent, nothing matters.’ The marks are not conclusions to brood over but observations the tradition turns toward release: understanding all things as impermanent, unsatisfactory, and selfless is described as freeing the mind from desire, hatred, and ignorance [3]. The doctrine is also framed as a value-neutral natural order [4] — the flux runs regardless of anyone’s approval, and the teaching simply maps it. Precisely because nothing conditioned repeats exactly, the tradition reads attention and care as urgent rather than optional.

‘The three marks are just the Four Noble Truths renamed.’ Della Santina lists them as companion teachings — the marks alongside the Four Noble Truths, karma, dependent origination, and the aggregates within wisdom’s doctrinal content [2] — but they are not the same teaching. The four truths map a problem, its cause, its cessation, and a path; the three marks describe what every conditioned thing is like, whatever one does about it. Insight into the marks is traditionally the engine of the path’s wisdom, not a restatement of it.

Taking the Teaching Further

The three marks compress a great deal into few syllables: reality flows (aniccā), the flow cannot be secured (dukkha), and no fixed self owns it (anattā) — with not-self alone extending to the unconditioned release the teaching aims at. In the Pali sources gathered for this guide, understanding the marks is not an academic conclusion but a realization the tradition places at the center of the path itself [1].

Three directions connect naturally from here. The Four Noble Truths show how this diagnosis becomes a practice program; the five aggregates show what the tradition analyzes when it dissolves ‘the self’ into processes; and dependent origination explains why the stream flows at all. In practice terms, vipassanā sources describe how the marks are observed, while the Mahayana route extends the third mark into the emptiness of all things. The glossary entries for terms such as saṅkhārā, dukkha, and vipassanā will carry the vocabulary forward as you read.

FAQ

Do all Buddhist traditions teach the three marks?

The ideas are broadly shared, but formulations differ. The Pali tradition uses the marks both as teaching and as a way of distinguishing Buddhist from non-Buddhist positions; Tibetan traditions render the term as 'three seals' (phyag rgya gsum) and often expand it to the 'four seals'; Mahayana sources develop not-self into the emptiness of all phenomena. What varies is emphasis, vocabulary, and the doctrinal work each tradition does with them.

How do the Sanskrit and Pali terms differ?

The Pali aniccā, dukkha, and anattā correspond to Sanskrit anitya, duḥkha, and anātman, and the collective term is trilakṣaṇa in Sanskrit against tilakkhaṇa in Pali. It is the same teaching in two languages of transmission, so readers will meet both sets in modern books.

Is dukkha in the three marks the same as the First Noble Truth?

They share a root concept but are used differently. The Four Noble Truths present dukkha as the predicament the Buddha diagnosed and linked to a cause, a cessation, and a path; as a mark, dukkha is stated of all conditioned things, characterizing experience itself. Della Santina lists the marks and the Four Noble Truths as companion teachings within the tradition's account of wisdom.

Does realizing the three marks count as enlightenment?

In the Pali tradition, yes: according to the Visuddhimagga, realization of the truth of the three marks constitutes enlightenment, a position the Encyclopedia of Buddhism records. Other traditions describe realization in their own terms; the sources cited here represent the Pali framing rather than a universal definition.

Where can I read the formula in translation?

Start with Dhammapada verses 277–279 in the Pali Canon, where the three statements appear as consecutive verses. The Encyclopedia of Buddhism entry quotes the full Pali formula, and SuttaCentral hosts English translations of the early Pali texts in which the marks recur throughout.

References

  1. Encyclopedia of Buddhism. 'Three marks of existence.' https://encyclopediaofbuddhism.org/wiki/Three_marks_of_existence
  2. Della Santina, Peter. 'The Three Universal Characteristics of Existence.' DharmaNet International. https://www.dharmanet.org/Della3marks.htm
  3. Buddho.org. 'Anicca, Dukkha, Anattā: The Three Characteristics of Existence.' https://buddho.org/anicca-dukkha-anatta-the-three-characteristics-of-existence/
  4. Payutto, P. A. Buddhadhamma, chapter 3: 'Three Characteristics' (English web edition). https://buddhadhamma.github.io/three-characteristics.html

Related Terms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *