Short Answer
Readers who try to live generously often hit a practical wall: the people around them keep needing time, money, and attention, and the practitioner’s supply of all three runs out. This article answers the question that arises next — is setting a personal boundary compatible with Buddhist compassion? It gathers how four recent Buddhist writers and teachers address the problem, explains the terms they use, and marks clearly where the discussion comes from particular traditions rather than from a rule that binds all Buddhists.
The sources are three essays from Tricycle: The Buddhist Review — Lorne Ladner’s “Healthy Boundaries: Taking a Stand” (2009), Pilar Jennings’s “Boundaries Make Good Bodhisattvas” (2018), and Tara Anand’s “Is an Aspiring Bodhisattva Allowed to Have Boundaries?” (2024) — together with an edited transcript of a public lecture by Chan master Žarko Andričević [1][2][3][4]. These are reflections by practitioners and teachers writing for a general Buddhist readership, not canonical texts; where they interpret the tradition, this article says so.
Key Takeaways
- Buddhist literature does not use the word “boundaries,” but it addresses the underlying issue: generosity is praised, with warnings against giving that leads to regret or exhaustion [1].
- Ladner compares boundaries to the stake and wires that steady a young tree — supports applied early and relaxed as growth matures [1].
- Jennings presents the bodhisattva aspiration of bodhicitta as fully compatible with knowing when to say no [3].
- In Chan teaching, compassion and wisdom are inseparable — “the two wings of enlightenment” — and discerning limits belongs to wisdom as much as to compassion [4].
- Both extremes cause harm: boundaries held too tightly can stifle compassion’s maturity, while absent ones can destroy it at the start [1].
Why the Question Arises
Anand opens her essay with the tension stated plainly: “In a relationship, can one exude boundless compassion while simultaneously setting healthy boundaries?” [2]. Writing as a committed practitioner, she describes being torn between the aspiration to act selflessly in service of others and the desire to act on behalf of her own embodied self. Giving without limits, she reports, left her open to being taken advantage of or manipulated by people she loved, while setting limits brought doubt, guilt, and worry about her own kindness and motives [2]. She traces part of this reaction to childhood conditioning in a dysfunctional family where she was simply not aware that personal boundaries existed as a concept [2].
Ladner, writing fifteen years earlier, describes what is at stake when the question goes unaddressed: early in practice, a lack of healthy boundaries can leave compassion “blown away before it’s had a chance to take root” [1]. The anxiety these writers document, in other words, is not invented for this article — it is the reason they wrote.
Bodhicitta: The Mind Set on Awakening for All
Why does “boundless” compassion create this pressure? Much of the answer lies in vocabulary inherited from Mahayana Buddhism. Bodhicitta (Sanskrit) denotes the resolve to attain full awakening — and, crucially, to do so for everyone’s benefit. Jennings defines it as the wish “to be fully enlightened for the benefit of all” and recalls that encountering the teaching was “a powerful and poignant challenge to the narcissism that had influenced my upbringing” [3]. Bodhicitta sets the direction of a life toward others. The essays examined here ask whether that direction requires unlimited personal expenditure; their answer, developed below, is that it does not — though Anand treats the balance as an ongoing negotiation rather than a settled rule [2].
What the Tradition’s Warnings About Giving Actually Say
Ladner points to an established pattern in Buddhist teaching: “Buddhism praises the value of generosity but warns that you shouldn’t give something away if you’re likely to be upset later and regret giving it away” [1]. The same tradition, he notes, cautions against agreeing to do something for another person when it will likely lead to feeling exhausted [1]. In this framing, the moral quality of a gift depends partly on the giver’s actual capacity and state of mind: giving that turns into regret is treated as a failure of discernment rather than as extra virtue.
The article’s central simile follows from this:
“Boundaries play an interesting and sometimes complicated role in developing compassion. They are like the stake and wires that are used to help keep young trees rooted and growing straight.”
— Lorne Ladner, “Healthy Boundaries: Taking a Stand,” Tricycle, Fall 2009 [1]
A stake protects a sapling; left on forever, it constrains the tree it once saved. Ladner’s conclusion is explicitly about timing and skill: practitioners need “to become skillful at knowing when to apply boundaries and when to relax or release them,” since boundaries held too tightly can stifle compassion and keep it from reaching maturity [1].
Saying No Inside the Bodhisattva Ideal
Jennings frames her essay with unusual directness: its headline reads “Boundaries Make Good Bodhisattvas,” and its summary line states that “We can aspire to save all sentient beings—and still know when to say no” [3]. Her account of bodhicitta presents the vow as a corrective to self-preoccupied striving, not as the erasure of the person making it. Read this way — a reading belonging to Jennings, not a canonical ruling — a refusal that protects a practitioner’s long-term ability to serve sits inside the bodhisattva aspiration rather than against it. A depleted bodhisattva, on this logic, helps no one; Ladner’s warning about exhaustion points in the same direction [1][3].
Anand’s contribution is to keep the tension honest. In her telling, compassion without limits invited manipulation, while limits pursued without warmth produced guilt and self-doubt about her generosity and motives [2]. Neither pole resolves the question alone, which is why she treats boundary-setting as a continuing practice rather than a one-time decision.
Wisdom and Compassion as the Two Wings
The Chan perspective in Andričević’s lecture adds a structural reason for confidence in the balance. Compassion, he explains, is one of the most important positive emotions in Buddhism, and it is inseparable from wisdom: “You could say that wisdom and compassion are the two wings of enlightenment,” and “without compassion, there is no true wisdom, and without wisdom, there is no true compassion” [4]. Even the goal of liberation from suffering, in this account, is characterized by both virtues together [4].
For the boundary question, this pairing matters structurally. Judging when giving genuinely helps, when it quietly harms, and when a refusal is the honest answer is wisdom doing its half of the work alongside compassionate intention. Andričević locates the cultivation of compassion in meditation practice, particularly the “Divine Abodes” (brahmavihāra) [4]. In the tradition’s standard list, these cultivations are loving-kindness (mettā), compassion (karuṇā), sympathetic joy (muditā), and equanimity (upekkhā). Equanimity — the balanced mind traditionally associated with meeting pleasant and unpleasant circumstances alike — is the quality contemporary writers most often connect with steadier boundaries, though the portion of the lecture under discussion here does not develop that specific application [4].
A Modern Word for an Older Set of Concerns
It bears repeating that “boundary” is a modern psychological term: Ladner explicitly notes that Buddhist literature does not use the word, even though it addresses the underlying issue [1]. Anand likewise treats “personal boundaries” as a concept she had to discover as an adult, having grown up unaware of it [2]. Discussions like those gathered here therefore translate older concerns — about giving (dāna), capacity, regret, and exhaustion — into contemporary language, largely within Mahayana and Chan frames. Other Buddhist settings handle limits differently: monastic traditions, for example, regulate what a monastic may take on through formal codes rather than through the language of personal boundaries. Readers who want to compare these warnings directly with the earliest layers of the literature can search early discourses on giving through collections such as SuttaCentral, noting that the specific warnings above reach this article through Ladner’s summary of them [1].
An Illustrative Example
The following scenario is an editorial illustration, not a recorded event or teaching. Imagine a practitioner who volunteers one evening a week at a meditation center and is asked to take on a second. Past experience says that accepting every request ends in resentment — precisely the regret Ladner’s cited warnings mark as a signal to pause [1]. Declining the second evening, or asking for time to consider it, functions like the sapling’s stake: it protects a commitment the practitioner can actually sustain, and it communicates care for the community rather than indifference to it. The same illustration shows the opposite failure. If “no” hardened into a blanket refusal to help anyone, the boundaries would have stayed on too long and begun to stifle the very growth they were meant to protect [1].
Three Misreadings Worth Correcting
“Setting a boundary means my compassion has failed.” Anand’s essay exists largely because she felt exactly this — doubt, guilt, and worry about her own kindness, generosity, and motives [2]. The teachers cited argue very nearly the reverse: unlimited availability is often what erodes generosity, while limits that hold are what preserve it [1][2].
“Boundless compassion means unlimited giving.” In the bodhisattva framing, “boundless” describes the direction and scope of aspiration, not an open-ended schedule of obligations. Jennings’s summary line — aspire to save all beings, still know when to say no — makes that distinction the point of her essay [3].
“Once learned, a boundary is permanent.” Ladner’s simile is developmental by design: the stake serves the young tree and is relaxed as it matures [1]. The skill he identifies lies in timing, not in building a permanent fence.
Where the Discussion Leaves the Reader
Across the four sources, several points converge. Capacity matters: regret and exhaustion function as honest inward signals, not as evidence of moral failure [1]. Guilt deserves examination rather than automatic obedience; Anand’s account of tracing her own guilt to childhood conditioning is an example of that examination [2]. And the balance is found case by case — in Ladner’s phrase, by becoming “skillful at knowing when to apply boundaries and when to relax or release them” [1]. Two limits on this article itself: it summarizes contemporary essays and a lecture rather than scripture, and it offers no guarantee that boundary-setting will resolve a difficult relationship on its own. Readers facing intense situations — caregiving strain, family conflict, or dynamics involving manipulation — may find it worth adding guidance from qualified teachers within their own tradition to what these contemporary writers describe.
FAQ
Can meditation practice help someone set boundaries?
Andričević presents compassion as something cultivated through meditation, especially the divine abodes (brahmavihāra) [4]. None of the cited writers, however, gives step-by-step instructions for boundary-setting, and this article does not either; the connection is drawn at the level of general cultivation and discernment.
Do all Buddhist traditions treat boundaries the same way?
No. The sources discussed here draw mainly on Mahayana-inflected themes — the bodhisattva and bodhicitta — and on Chan teaching, while other settings address limits through different means, such as monastic codes. None of the cited writers claims to state a rule for every Buddhist; the shared thread is that limits and compassion are treated as compatible.
Is it selfish to refuse a request for help?
The cited writers distinguish a refusal that protects sustainable generosity from one that shields indifference. Jennings argues that bodhisattvas can know when to say no, and Ladner cites warnings against giving the giver will later regret [1][3]. They treat motive and capacity as the relevant measures, not a count of favors granted.

Leave a Reply