Secular Buddhism: Modern Approaches and Points of Debate

Short Answer

Secular Buddhism—also called the secular dharma—is a modern, largely English-language movement that reinterprets the Buddha’s teachings for people who do not accept traditional religious claims on faith. Scholars describe it as a diffuse, quasi-religious movement with no central authority, emerging in the last decade of the twentieth century. Practitioners follow at least three broad paths, and internal debates center on Stephen Batchelor’s task-based reading of the Four Noble Truths and on the meaning of the word “secular” itself. This article surveys the movement’s background, approaches, and points of contention.

Secular Buddhism is a contemporary movement—also called the secular dharma—that presents the Buddha’s teachings in language and practices compatible with a modern, non-traditional outlook. In the Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Religion, Richard K. Payne and Casey Alexandra Kemp describe it as a “quasi-religious movement” that began in the last decade of the twentieth century and remains diffuse, without “hierarchical authority capable of defining and enforcing orthodoxy” [1]. Because no institution speaks for the movement, the clearest way to understand it is through its practitioners’ own approaches and arguments: which paths they follow, how they reinterpret core teachings, and where they disagree. This article covers that ground. Its scope is the modern, largely English-language movement only; it does not describe Buddhism as a whole, and traditional schools and communities continue alongside it.

What the term “secular Buddhism” names

Secular Buddhism
A loose contemporary orientation, also known as the secular dharma, in which the Buddha’s teachings are treated as practices and perspectives one can adopt without traditional religious commitments. Participants debate both the content of those practices and the aptness of the word secular.

The word secular does significant work here—and it is part of the movement’s own unresolved problem. Payne and Kemp trace one of its intellectual debts to Victorian apologetics, which sharpened the Western habit of dividing the world into “religion” and “non-religion” [1]. Some practitioners accept that division and place the dharma on the non-religious side; others, discussed below, argue that this framing misdescribes what Buddhist life involves. Since nothing in the movement defines and enforces orthodoxy, “secular Buddhism” functions more like a shared family of projects than a membership category [1].

Where the movement comes from

The scholarly account is a reconstruction, not the movement’s own founding story. Payne and Kemp locate the movement’s beginnings in the 1990s but read them against a longer background: modernizing trends in nineteenth-century Asia, and a series of Western inheritances—liberal Protestant thought emphasizing religious experience and social action; Victorian apologetics; the Perennialist teaching that all religions share a common mystical core; and, in their critical assessment, neoliberalism’s focus on “the isolated individual as the locus of agency, existing in competition with others” [1].

Two points in that account deserve emphasis. First, secular Buddhism did not arise in a vacuum: its characteristic concerns—experience over doctrine, practice over ritual authority—resemble patterns that shaped other modern Buddhist currents. Second, the scholars’ framing is evaluative as well as descriptive; the connection to neoliberal individualism is their interpretation, which practitioners might dispute. The Oxford entry also notes that, despite lacking institutional authority, the movement has been shaped by “the important role of some leading figures” [1]. Among these, Stephen Batchelor—whose work is discussed below—has become the most publicly associated name.

Three paths practitioners take

In a 2019 essay for the Secular Buddhist Network—a website that serves as a hub for the movement’s discussions—writer Mike Slott identified three broad approaches, and they offer an insiders’ map of their own terrain [2]:

  • Reconstruction: “the project of reconstructing traditional Buddhism in order to create a modern version of the dharma.” Slott adds that this approach is “primarily situated within Buddhism” [2].
  • Secular mindfulness: developing a mindfulness movement rooted in Buddhist meditative practice as a component of therapeutic and educational practices [2].
  • Social transformation: incorporating the Buddha’s insights about human experience into “a radical movement for human liberation and social transformation” [2].

Slott presents the three as “not mutually exclusive,” so a practitioner may take part in all of them to some extent [2]. The distinction still matters for readers, because the same label can cover anything from reworking canonical material to community organizing or therapeutic applications of meditation.

The movement’s internal debates

Because no authority settles questions, public debate is a constitutive feature of the movement rather than a breakdown in it. The Secular Buddhist Network states that it has hosted “several important debates about the meaning and role of secular Buddhism” [3]. Two stand out for anyone trying to understand the movement: the status of the Four Noble Truths, and the meaning of the word secular.

Truths or tasks?

Batchelor’s most discussed proposal reinterprets the Four Noble Truths as “a fourfold task to facilitate human flourishing,” which the site describes as the most well-known aspect of his effort to develop a secular approach to the dharma [3]. The stakes are easy to state. If the four truths are propositions about reality, the natural response is assent. If they are tasks, the natural response is action. Traditional presentations have generally foregrounded the first; Batchelor foregrounds the second and treats the shift as radical.

An editorial example, offered as illustration rather than as a quotation from any ancient text, can make the contrast concrete. The traditional first truth is often rendered as “there is dukkha” (dukkha is the Pali word customarily translated as suffering, stress, or unsatisfactoriness). A truth-first reading invites the student to evaluate whether that claim is accurate. A task-first reading turns the same item into an assignment: come to a clearer, first-hand understanding of the stress in your life. Whether that reinterpretation faithfully recovers the Buddha’s teaching or departs from it is exactly what the movement’s participants dispute.

The exchange itself is a multilogue. Mike Slott, whom the site describes as strongly supportive of Batchelor’s approach, raised concerns about how truths and tasks relate in Batchelor’s view; Winton Higgins replied; Slott answered Higgins; and Batchelor then responded, arguing that the crucial point is “the radical shift from truth-based religion to a task-based ethics” [3]. Reviewing the dialogue, Jonathan Golden drew on Thomas Kuhn’s notion of a “paradigm shift”—the idea that revolutions replace whole frameworks rather than amend details—to weigh in on Slott’s side [3]. As of the 2021 documentation, the conversation remained open, and both sides are participants in the secular project rather than opponents of it.

Why one prominent writer declined the label

In late 2020, writer Seth Zuihō Segall published “Why I Am Not a Secular Buddhist,” initiating a sustained exchange with Winton Higgins [4]. Segall’s own position, developed in his book Buddhism and Human Flourishing, is a eudaimonic approach—the term derives from the Greek eudaimonia, human flourishing—and the site notes that it is similar to secular Buddhism in many respects [4]. His objection is to the label more than to the project: in the site’s summary, his primary concern is that the term “secular” “connotes the rejection of religion as a whole and negates the sacred dimension of our lived experience in the world” [4].

Higgins, in turn, is a leading proponent of the secular approach rather than a defender of traditional religion. He is the author of After Buddhism: A Workbook, a step-by-step companion to Batchelor’s book After Buddhism, and has written numerous articles arguing for secular approaches to meditation, the role of the sangha (practitioner community), and social and political engagement grounded in values of care and compassion [4]. Their exchange shows that the disagreement is partly about words and the status of the sacred, not simply about whether to practice. That a writer whose approach overlaps substantially with the movement rejects its name is good evidence that “secular Buddhism” is not a settled brand even among those close to it [4].

Common misunderstandings

  • “It is one organization.” There is no central body, lineage, or enforced orthodoxy; the movement is diffuse [1].
  • “It is simply Buddhism minus religion.” Even insiders dispute whether the label describes their orientation accurately [4].
  • “It is the same thing as the mindfulness industry.” Secular mindfulness is one path associated with the movement, not its entirety [2].
  • “It rejects the Four Noble Truths.” The best-known secular position reinterprets the truths as tasks rather than discarding them—and that reinterpretation is itself contested [3].

Key takeaways

  • Secular Buddhism is a diffuse modern movement, also called the secular dharma, with no central authority [1].
  • Scholars place its emergence in the 1990s, with deeper roots in nineteenth-century Asian modernization and Western religious categories [1].
  • Practitioners pursue at least three paths: reconstructing the dharma, secular mindfulness, and social transformation [2].
  • The most prominent debate concerns Batchelor’s fourfold task reading of the Four Noble Truths [3].
  • The label “secular” itself is contested, as the Segall–Higgins exchange demonstrates [4].

For readers who want to go further, the primary exchanges are documented on the Secular Buddhist Network—Slott’s essay on the three paths [2], the site’s debates roundup [3], and the Segall–Higgins dialogue [4]—best read against the Oxford encyclopedia’s scholarly assessment [1].

FAQ

Is secular Buddhism a religion?

Scholars have described it as a “quasi-religious movement” rather than a conventional religion [1]. Within the movement, the question is debated: some participants embrace the non-religious framing, while Seth Zuihō Segall argues that the “secular” label wrongly negates the sacred dimension of lived experience [4].

Did Stephen Batchelor found secular Buddhism?

No single founder exists; the movement is diffuse and lacks any authority capable of defining orthodoxy [1]. Batchelor is among its best-known figures, and his fourfold task reading of the Four Noble Truths is the movement’s most publicized proposal [3].

Do secular Buddhists still meditate?

Yes, in general. One of the three broad paths identified by Mike Slott is developing a secular mindfulness movement rooted in Buddhist meditative practice [2], and Winton Higgins has written on secular approaches to meditation, though the sources do not promise specific benefits from any practice [4].

References

  1. Richard K. Payne and Casey Alexandra Kemp. “Secular Buddhism.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Religion, Oxford University Press, published 29 September 2021. https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/62249/chapter/551435786
  2. Mike Slott. “Three paths for secular Buddhists – crucial conversations and movements.” Secular Buddhist Network, 9 August 2019. https://secularbuddhistnetwork.org/three-paths-for-secular-buddhists/
  3. Mike Slott. “Debates and Dialogues on Secular Buddhism.” Secular Buddhist Network, 25 September 2021. https://secularbuddhistnetwork.org/debates-and-dialogues-on-secular-buddhism/
  4. SBN Editor. “Seth Zuihō Segall and Winton Higgins debate the meaning and value of secular Buddhism.” Secular Buddhist Network, 19 November 2020. https://secularbuddhistnetwork.org/seth-zuiho-segall-and-winton-higgins-debate-the-meaning-and-value-of-secular-buddhism/

Related Terms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *